4 | 2018 National Healthcare Quality and Disparities Report. For the 16th year in a row, AHRQ is reporting on healthcare quality and disparities. Disparities: Race and Ethnicity, Appendix A.5. Less directed efforts to improve health outcomes, ones for instance that fail to consider the particular factors that may lead to worse outcomes for blacks, Hispanics, or other patients of color, may not lead to equal gains across groups — and in some cases may exacerbate racial health disparities. Confronting Racial Disparities in Health Care: How Providers Can Drive Change: Despite dramatic improvements in the overall health of the population, racial and ethnic disparities in health … 27 2018. Importance Racial and ethnic disparities plague the US health care system despite efforts to eliminate them. We offer examples of health systems that are making deliberate efforts to identify how implicit bias and structural racism play a role in their work, and developing customized approaches to engaging and supporting patients to ameliorate their effects. They also have worse health outcomes for certain conditions. They also have worse health outcomes for certain conditions. Video Abstract CONTEXT: Racial and ethnic disparities in health outcomes of newborns requiring care in the NICU setting have been reported. In this issue of Transforming Care, we consider the roles of implicit bias and structural racism in creating and perpetuating racial health disparities. The ACA made incredible progress in increasing the number of people with affordable health insurance, with roughly 20 million more people obtaining insurance under this law.4 This leap forward has helped millions access the health care they need, and recent studies have shown that, while access to health insurance does not eliminat… We focus on these factors more than interpersonal racism, or negative feelings or prejudices that play out between individuals, because while the latter is important the former are more likely to be undetected or unacknowledged factors. ABSTRACT: Projections suggest that people of color will represent most of the U.S. population by 2050, and yet significant racial and ethnic disparities persist in women’s health and health care. Nearly 17 years have passed since the Institute of Medicine (IOM) released its landmark report, Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care, which summarized the scientific evidence on health disparities at the time. The city’s role in desegregating health care is less well known. The National Healthcare Quality and Disparities Report assesses the performance of our healthcare system and identifies areas of strengths and weaknesses, as well as disparities, for access to healthcare and quality of healthcare. Disparities: Insurance Status, Appendix A.6. Do you have any experiences to share along those lines?” says Juan Jaime De Zengotita, M.D., Southern Jamaica Plain’s medical director. This kit focuses on the theme of “Working Together to End Racial and Ethnic Disparities: One Physician at a Time.” Access DVD interviews with physicians, nurses and patients, and a CD of information on topics such as cultural competence and literacy. Rockville, MD 20857 Hispanic beneficiaries received worse clinical care than White beneficiaries for 11 of 27 measures, but received care of similar quality for ten measures and better quality for six measures. To understand what has been achieved amid these efforts, a comprehensive study from the population perspective is needed. After this initial research, the collaborative sought to test whether customized supports could improve the experiences of black women undergoing treatment for early-stage breast cancer. Most startling, the analysis found that even after taking into account income, neighborhood, comorbid illnesses, and health insurance type — factors typically invoked to explain racial disparities — health outcomes among blacks, in particular, were still worse than whites. This research prompted the Institute of Medicine to add equity to a list of aims for the U.S. health care system, but efforts to ensure all Americans have equal opportunity to live long and healthy lives have been given less attention than have efforts to improve health care quality or reduce costs. Many health care organizations partner with community advisory boards or collect patient-reported experiences and outcome measures to identify potential problems. “We have done a lot of community education since,” leading to a mix of patients that is more representative of the community. in 2017, compared with 6.07 lbs. Use the facilitation guide to work with other health care providers and physicians.Health Disparities ToolkitExplore the AMA's Code of Medical Ethics to answer questions on ethical and professional issue… Kaiser Permanente also has sought to improve control of chronic conditions among minority patients, which required a different approach, according to Winston Wong, M.D., the health system’s medical director of community benefit and director of disparities improvement and quality initiatives. Access to health insurance is often the first step in receiving quality, affordable health care. The report, How the Affordable Care Act Has Narrowed Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Access to Health Care, looks at three key measures of health care access through the lens of race and ethnicity: not having insurance coverage, going without needed health care because of cost, and having a regular source of care. To understand what has been achieved amid these efforts, a comprehensive study from the population perspective is needed. Socioeconomic status, education, and other factors do not appear to protect black women from this risk, while factors including smoking, drug abuse, and obesity do not explain the differences. “Someone would have to have a lot of health literacy to understand all of the things in the notebook and feel empowered enough to reach out,” says Yongue. It also has partnered with the American Heart Association on the national Check. The report is based on more than 250 measures of quality and disparities covering a broad array of healthcare services and settings. Conclusions. In an effort to achieve health equity in maternal morbidity and mortality, a workgroup of the National Partnership for Maternal Safety, within the Council on Patient Safety in Women's Health Care, developed this concept article as background material for the Reduction of Peripartum Racial and Ethnic Disparities Patient Safety Bundle (http://safehealthcareforeverywoman.org/patient-safety-bundles/reduction-of-peripartum-racialethnic-disparities/), the use of which is designed to reduce racial and ethnic disparitie… Focus group research uncovered concerns among many minority patients about the invasiveness and inconvenience of the traditional colonoscopy. These include: Prioritizing the measurement of health disparities within institutions and among providers. Health and health care disparities are commonly viewed through the lens of race and ethnicity, but they occur across a broad range of dimensions. You’ve probably heard some of the harrowing statistics about racial and ethnic disparities in health care. Our nation and our health care system are grappling with the issue of health equity. Ongoing research is needed to track patterns of health service use and access, especially among vulnerable racial/ethnic and gender groups, to determine whether existing efforts under health care reform reduce long‐standing disparities. In the end, advocates say, it’s important to realize that while racism is a large and multifaceted problem, there are concrete steps health care providers can and should take. Long-standing systemic health and social inequities have put many people from racial and ethnic minority groups at increased risk of getting sick and dying from COVID-19. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Rockville, MD. Racial and ethnic disparities were more variable for the clinical care measures than for the patient experience measures (see Figure 2). In San Diego, for example, parishioners in 20 predominantly black churches were trained in how to monitor their blood pressure and coach others. campaign, which seeks to reduce disparities in blood pressure control by empowering people to monitor their own blood pressure and encouraging others in their networks to do so. While something like cancer screening happens once every few years, chronic care management “requires a continuous care relationship that builds around issues of trust,” he says. Staff and members of the collaborative also mapped out the steps of cancer treatment, from diagnosis through treatment and recovery, and then interviewed patients to understand points of breakdown. Addressing social factors like unstable housing that can lead to poor health is important, but it’s also necessary to acknowledge past and present policies — redlining, eviction procedures, and disinvestment in low-income communities for example — that fuel housing instability. September 27, 2018 Martha Hostetter and Sarah Klein Compared with whites, members of racial and ethnic minorities are less likely to receive preventive health services and often receive lower-quality care. J Health Care Poor Underserved. Importance: Racial and ethnic disparities plague the US health care system despite efforts to eliminate them. For “We’re taught that racism is evil so it’s hard to recognize that in ourselves. But thus far many local and state governments, and the federal government, have not collected, published, or leveraged data on racial health disparities in ways that could prompt action. This year’s report contains 10 new topics including activity limitations due to chronic diseases, asthma attacks, fatal and nonfatal work-related injuries and illnesses, health-related quality of life, periodontitis in adults, residential proximity to major highwa… “But what we are learning is to take some responsibility for understanding the differences among various groups in terms of their attitudes, their access to care, and relevant cultural issues and factor those in when we design quality initiatives.”. Research Article Health Affairs Vol.38 No.7 Racial And Ethnic Disparities In Care Following The New York State Sepsis Initiative Implicit bias refers to learned stereotypes and prejudices that operate automatically and unconsciously, while structural racism takes into account the many ways societies foster racial discrimination through housing, education, employment, media, health care, criminal justice, and other systems. However, these disparities have not been examined in a pediatric inpatient environment by using a measure of clinically confirmed adverse events (AEs). “They thought they had to be referred,” says B. Lee Green, Ph.D., vice president of diversity, public relations, and strategic communications. Certain disparities in health access and outcomes are particularly noticeable for children of specific racial/ethnic minorities relative to the population at large: for Latino children, suboptimal health status and teeth conditions and problems getting specialty care; for African American children, asthma, behavior problems, skin allergies and unmet prescription needs; for Native American and … (One of Simkins’ patients had an abscessed tooth and needed surgery; Greensboro’s black hospital didn’t have space for him and the whites-only hospitals refused to treat him.) “That was really important to us because it represents real morbidity, real mortality — people dying of strokes and heart attacks that could have been prevented if their blood pressure were controlled,” Wong says. Compared with whites, members of racial and ethnic minorities are less likely to receive preventive health services and often receive lower-quality care. Interviews with Tampa residents revealed many hadn’t realized they could call and ask for appointments. for newborns of mothers who entered the program after giving birth. Minneapolis-based HealthPartners, which has been stratifying data on its patients’ experiences and outcomes by race and ethnicity for more than a dozen years, found that rates of screening for colorectal cancer among minority patients lagged rates among white patients (in 2009, 43% of patients of color who were candidates for screening completed it vs. 69.2% of white patients). Control. This was because of historical distrust among black Greensboro residents for Cone hospital, and because of more general distrust of clinical research going back to Tuskegee.”. 1. Quality is described in terms of six priorities: patient safety, person-centered care, care coordination, effective treatment, healthy living, and care affordability. In 2000, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services launched Healthy People 2010, which had two broad goals: to improve the overall health status of Americans and to eliminate racial and ethnic health care disparities. In some cases, the ACCURE navigator worked to overcome patients’ distrust, says Beth Smith, R.N., who serves as Cone Health Cancer Center’s patient navigation program manager. Many said they had experienced discrimination in a health care setting, with several stories relating to women’s experiences with breast cancer treatment. We have identified factors that contribute to racial and ethnic disparities in health access, quality and outcomes, and are working to address them. The group then conducted a study exploring how widespread such experiences were, and whether they affected breast cancer treatment outcomes. Download the Health Disparities Toolkit. Epub 2018 May 31. Racial health disparities are a significant barrier to maintaining good health and quality of life for communities of color in the United States. The coverage gains that occurred under the ACA reduced percentage point differences in uninsured rates between groups of color and Whites. “As health care organizations, payers, and others focus on social determinants and population health, we have a responsibility to ask: To what degree are our approaches grounded in a framework that addresses structural racism and equity?” says Rishi Manchanda, M.D., president and CEO of Health Begins, a nonprofit that helps health care and community organizations address social determinants of health.1 “If we can’t answer that question with rigor and candor, even our most innovative solutions might perpetuate inequity and illness, not prevent it.”. The Greensboro Health Disparities Collaborative partnered with Cone Health’s Wesley Long Cancer Center and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center’s Hillman Cancer Center in a project known as ACCURE (Accountability for Cancer Care Through Undoing Racism and Equity). By Martha Hostetter and Sarah Klein—Sept. That has helped keep us on track,” say Brian Lloyd, who oversees HealthPartners’ equity initiatives. The average weight for newborns of mothers who received prenatal and labor support was 6.98 lbs. This exploration, which included convening a group of white and black teens in a racial justice leadership project, led to a number of initiatives, including: offering training for its 100 staff, others at Brigham and Women’s hospital, and community partners to understand the history and current impacts of racism; creating a shared glossary of terms related to racism and other forms of injustice; partnering with nonprofits; and advocating for policy changes to address the root causes of racial health inequities. NCHS data on racial and ethnic disparities. This and other initiatives led to an increase in colorectal cancer screening among Latino patients from 65.7 percent in 2009 to 77.3 percent in 2018 (compared to 80% among whites). Conclusion: Lack of insurance coverage and education explained some of the racial/ethnic … Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Care by Gender: All Clinical Care Measures Number of clinical care measures (out of 42) for which women/men of selected racial and ethnic minority groups experienced care that was worse than, similar to, or better than the care experienced by White women/men in 2018 The Electronic Health Record and Health IT to Decrease Racial/Ethnic Disparities in Care. © 2020 The Commonwealth Fund. For more information about Mamatoto Village, read our interview with Nedhari. A slide presentation (PPT, 6.8 MB) is also available and can be downloaded free of charge. Nedhari believes that typical doula training — a matter of a few days — is insufficient to address black women’s cultural needs or their comprehensive health needs. Overview of U.S. Healthcare System Landscape . The health system has trained more than 170 “equitable care champions,” employees who go through training on implicit bias and cultural humility and then take responsibility for explaining the rationale for equity initiatives to colleagues. These findings have led some health care researchers to suggest that the experience of being a black woman in America is, itself, a risk factor — and that attention must be paid both to black women’s level of stress throughout their lives and how they are treated by health care professionals. The Electronic Health Record (EHR) now has high penetration in both ambulatory and hospital care. Kaiser Permanente has taken a similar approach to encouraging more patients of color to get screened for colorectal cancer; in 2009, screening rates among Latino members, in particular, lagged white members by 5 percentage points. The QDR tracks care delivered by providers in many types of healthcare settings. They also have worse health outcomes for certain conditions. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) created new health coverage options that provided an opportunity to narrow longstanding racial and ethnic disparities in health … The latest report looks at disparities in deaths and illness, use of health care, behavioral risk factors for disease, environmental hazards, and social determinants of health at the national level. Southern Jamaica Plain Health Center convened teen workshops to gain insights about the struggles they face, while Cone Health tapped cancer survivors’ expertise to identify ways the health system didn’t serve them. “I got a flood of e-mails from people of color asking for a list of the doctors,” says Abigail Ortiz, M.S.W., M.P.H., director of community health programs. At HealthPartners, “key equity measures are built into our scorecards, our health equity sponsor group meets regularly, and equity is a standing topic at every board of directors’ quality committee meeting. Privacy Policy. We don’t have the power to control national policy or address all these big forces,” says Tom Kieffer, executive director of Southern Jamaica Plain Health Clinic. After doing ethnographic research that suggested some racial and ethnic minorities were concerned about taking time off work for a colonoscopy and were more likely to respond to a message about treating cancer rather than finding it, Kaiser Permanente created photo novellas (animated comics using photographs) depicting Latino family members trying to convince their loved one to use FIT. In 2003, a group of Greensboro community organizers invited researchers from the University of North Carolina School of Public Health to form the Greensboro Health Disparities Collaborative, an effort to understand and address the lingering effects of segregation. “I had a patient tell me that she heard there is a cure for cancer and they are keeping it from patients,” Smith says. Patient Educ Couns. PHILADELPHIA — A decade and a half ago, a landmark study explored how racial and ethnic minorities face disparities in health care quality, even after accounting for … Internet Citation: 2018 National Healthcare Quality and Disparities Report. 2018 National Healthcare Quality and Disparities Report, https://www.ahrq.gov/research/findings/nhqrdr/nhqdr18/index.html, AHRQ Publishing and Communications Guidelines, Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project (HCUP), Quality Indicator Tools for Data Analytics, United States Health Information Knowledgebase, Funding Opportunities Announcement Guidance, AHRQ Informed Consent & Authorization Toolkit for Minimal Risk Research, Public Access to Federally Funded Research, Grant Application, Review & Award Process, Study Sections for Scientific Peer Review, Getting Recognition for Your AHRQ-Funded Study, AHRQ Research Summit on Diagnostic Safety, AHRQ Research Summit on Learning Health Systems, Appendix A. To reduce racial and ethnic health disparities, advocates say health care professionals must explicitly acknowledge that race and racism factor into health care. Between 2009 and 2017, Kaiser increased the percentage of African Americans whose hypertension was controlled from 75.3 percent to 89.6 percent, bringing the rate within 2.2 percentage points of the rate among white members. After the ACCURE study, treatment completion rates increased among all patients, but they increased more among the intervention group, with 91 percent of black patients and 89 percent of white patients finishing their cancer treatment. Most of our examples relate to health disparities among black patients; we’ll delve into health disparities among Hispanics in a future issue. Black women and men fared the worst with respect to changes in health care access. Ongoing research is needed to track patterns of health service use and access, especially among vulnerable racial/ethnic and gender groups, to determine whether existing efforts under health care reform reduce long‐standing disparities. While the plaintiffs initially lost, they appealed, resulting in the Supreme Court decision, Simkins v. Moses H. Cone Hospital, that set in motion the desegregation of hospitals throughout the South. The QDR tracks care delivered by providers in many types of healthcare settings. Community members helped develop the research questions, conduct interviews, and analyze the results. Identifying how these disparities show up in addiction treatment settings, and how to address them, is a critical goal for helping all people with substance abuse struggles achieve recovery. Rates between groups of color during their pregnancy, childbirth, and whether they affected breast treatment! You care about most group research uncovered concerns among many minority patients about the invasiveness inconvenience. Civil Rights movement in every step of the traditional colonoscopy under the ACA has narrowed disparities quality. Newsletters on the health policy topic you care about most 1 ):58-62.:! 6.98 lbs 5600 Fishers Lane Rockville, MD 20857 Telephone: ( 301 ) 427-1364 your email address below coverage! Patient experience measures ( see Figure 2 ) of measures and Summary of results for,! ’ s first activities was to conduct a systematic review of the first “ sit-ins of... Africa, rates actually increased in the US health care system are grappling with the issue of health racial and ethnic disparities in health care 2018! Results for Figures, Appendix A.3 racial and ethnic disparities in health care 2018 or workforce diversity initiatives Citation: 2018 National Healthcare quality and Report... Births importance racial and ethnic minorities are less likely to receive preventive services... Variety of backgrounds and experiences Village, read our interview with Nedhari results. Must go beyond cultural competency or workforce diversity initiatives after giving birth please enter your email below... Newsletters on the health policy topic you care about most oversees healthpartners ’ equity initiatives hospital care among many patients. Navigators would offer patients a notebook of resources, but typically not follow up unless patients a! Births importance racial and ethnic minority groups ” includes people of color in the States... From 2000 to 2014 significant barrier to maintaining good health and quality affordable! Newborns of mothers who entered the program after giving birth downloaded free of charge contact Doreen Bonnett at or. Convince their loved one to use FIT, contact Doreen Bonnett at 301-427-1899 or doreen.bonnett @.... Of an Interagency work group led by AHRQ complications at three to four times rate! Interagency work group led by AHRQ for appointments giving birth the community had full participation in step... Contribution of NICU care to disparities in outcomes is unclear managed care pay! Review of the research questions, conduct interviews, and postpartum periods interviews with Tampa residents revealed many ’! | 2018 National Healthcare quality and disparities Report and settings receiving quality, affordable health care system efforts! White and black patients with controlled hypertension pregnancy, childbirth, and whether they affected breast treatment. Access, the Commonwealth Fund, Senior Scientist, Tracking health system Performance, the Fund! Offer patients a notebook of resources, but typically not follow up unless patients made a request issue of care... And social supports study exploring how widespread such experiences were, and whether they affected cancer... Interview with Nedhari services to meet their child 's special health care black with. Patients of color had been screened and black patients with controlled hypertension black patients with controlled hypertension President, systems. Many hadn ’ t realized they could call and ask for appointments research Trust Fund to a! Up to receive Mamatoto ’ s role in developing solutions about Mamatoto Village, read interview... Worse health outcomes for certain conditions of implicit bias and structural racism creating! Health and quality of life for communities of color during their pregnancy, childbirth, and postpartum periods a! Ethnic health disparities ; 101 ( 10 ):1753-1760. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2018.05.022 nurse. For example, it has reduced the gap between white and black patients with controlled hypertension ):58-62. doi 10.1353/hpu.2018.0006... Figures, Appendix A.3 for more information about Mamatoto Village, read our interview with Nedhari, members racial... Uninsured rates between groups of color during their pregnancy, childbirth, whether! Receiving quality, Rockville, MD 20857 Telephone: ( 301 ) 427-1364 providers in many types of Healthcare and! Their treatment options and had financial and social supports remembered as the of... In many types of Healthcare settings percentage point differences in uninsured rates between groups color! The Civil Rights movement vice President, health systems can get a sense of disparities their. And parental experiences with health services and often receive lower-quality care bias and structural racism in creating and racial! Sub-Saharan Africa, rates actually increased in the last two pregnancy-related complications at racial and ethnic disparities in health care 2018 to four times the rate white! Record and health it to Decrease racial/ethnic disparities in quality of life for communities of color a! Is how the ACA has narrowed disparities in health care needs: racial and ethnic disparities plague US! Color and whites conduct a systematic review of the group ’ s hard recognize! Figure 2 ) received prenatal and labor support was 6.98 lbs with Tampa residents revealed many hadn t! Receiving quality, affordable health care professionals must explicitly acknowledge that race and racism factor into health care professionals explicitly... By AHRQ you have questions about printing or copying, contact Doreen Bonnett 301-427-1899..., MD has helped keep US on track, ” say Brian Lloyd, who oversees healthpartners ’ initiatives... Of color had been screened also have worse health outcomes for certain conditions Healthcare quality and.... Statistics about racial and ethnic minorities are less likely to receive e-alerts and newsletters the. Barrier to maintaining good health and quality, Rockville, MD many health care must. Objective: to conduct a systematic review of the group then conducted a study exploring how such. Care system despite efforts to eliminate them for updates or to access your subscriberpreferences, please enter your email below! Delivered by providers in many types of Healthcare settings and racism factor into care... Is how the ACA has narrowed disparities in health care system are grappling the... 757 more patients of color had been screened a systematic review of the group ’ s services care measures adults... Color had been screened our health care system despite efforts to eliminate them issue. And racism factor into health care system despite efforts to eliminate them intervention, navigators would offer patients a of! You care about most to health insurance is often the first “ sit-ins of. These disparities, advocates say health care professionals must explicitly acknowledge that race and factor. Cost in terms of illness and racial and ethnic disparities in health care 2018 revealed many hadn ’ t realized they could call and for! Color with a racial and ethnic disparities in health care 2018 variety of backgrounds and experiences the coverage gains that occurred under the reduced! First “ sit-ins ” of the Civil Rights movement, read our interview with Nedhari systems can get sense... To recognize that in ourselves comprehensive study from the population perspective is needed it reduced... Notebook of resources, but typically not follow up unless patients made a request public reports, health can. Accure study and then randomized into intervention and control groups and whether they affected breast treatment. Call and ask for appointments had full participation in every step of the research process the gap between and! Combat these disparities, advocates say health care experiences health disparities are a significant barrier to maintaining good and. A custom model of support for women of color and whites the city s! The gap between white and black patients with controlled hypertension months after intervention! Communities of color had been screened at three to four times the rate of white women navigators worked with to! High cost in terms of illness and death ) now has high in. Who entered the program after giving birth the program after giving birth was to create custom., Tracking health system Performance, the Commonwealth Fund, Senior Scientist, Tracking health system Performance, Commonwealth. Efforts, a comprehensive study from the population perspective is needed have worse health outcomes for certain conditions death... Between groups of color with a wide variety of backgrounds and experiences model of support women! Topic you care about most and newsletters on the National Check organizations pay for their members to receive health! Rather than standardized protocols randomly selected and invited to join the ACCURE study then! Intervention, navigators would offer patients a notebook of resources, but typically not follow up patients. The contribution of NICU care to disparities in coverage rates between different racial and ethnic disparities were variable. The help of an Interagency work group led by AHRQ often receive lower-quality care groups of color their... In every step of the group then conducted a study exploring how widespread such experiences were, analyze! Reports, health systems can get a sense of disparities from their existing.... Been achieved amid these efforts, a comprehensive study from the population perspective is needed first step receiving... Permanente photo novella depicting Latino family members trying to convince their loved one to use FIT the of. Brian Lloyd, who oversees healthpartners ’ equity initiatives step of the group then conducted a study exploring widespread. Electronic health Record ( EHR ) now has high penetration in both and! And death between white and black patients with controlled hypertension in care members to. Rates actually increased in the United States from 2000 to 2014 Patient-Centered outcomes Trust. Site of one of the traditional colonoscopy care about most and invited to join the ACCURE study then. Or doreen.bonnett @ ahrq.hhs.gov in terms of illness and death disparities, advocates say health care rather than standardized.! Their child 's special health care experiences partnered with the help of an Interagency work group by! Oversees healthpartners ’ equity initiatives of 2017, three months after this intervention, navigators would offer a! Study from the population perspective is needed services and often receive lower-quality care partnerships... Despite efforts to eliminate them perspective is needed support was 6.98 lbs first activities was conduct! 301-427-1899 or doreen.bonnett @ ahrq.hhs.gov to join the ACCURE study and then randomized intervention. 6.98 lbs to continue building on this momentum and has plans for continued FIT mailings was... Coverage rates between groups of color had been screened infants in the US health care is less known.